The Beer Baron

Kirkland German Lager

2009-10-15T07:23:00.000-07:00

Kirkland German Lager: Color-Amber golden Nose-Slightly sweet First taste-Fast flavor; quick fade Observations-Not even; not level Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Where brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$.79 Saying-Alc#-5.5% (Considered malt liquor in Texas) Style-Domestic lager; German type Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Funky Rating-6.25
Factoid: One of four beer types made (by Utica Club Brewing) for Costco Wholesale. Strong similarity between Simpler Times (available at Trader Joe's) and this Kirkland product. BeerBaron

Mission St. IPA

2009-10-15T07:21:00.000-07:00

A trip to Trader's Joe's on Atlantic Ave. & Court St. in Brooklyn has unearthed a different IPA. I will do a quick evaluation and Gary & Rita will be excluded since it will be included in our October IPA festivities.
Mission St. IPA: Color-Amber yellow Nose-Hoppy First taste-Quick grapefruit Observations-Balanced Where Brewed? Paso Robles, Cal. Fizziness-Some head; active bubbles Cost-$1.16 Alc#-6.8% Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Lingering hops burst Rating-7.5
Mike Komaroff, BeerBaron

"Coney Island" Steel Hop Lager

2009-10-15T07:19:00.000-07:00

Fellow Beer Enthusiasts: The sexy sword swallower on the label; Coney Island rube figure as the cornerstone of Schmaltz Brewing. They are contract brewed out of Saratoga Springs, NY. Here goes:
Coney Island Steel Hop Lager: Color-Golden yellow Nose-Fresh, clean Fizziness-Steady head; active bubbles How obtained-Gift First taste-Slighty harsh; burst of flavor Observations-Substantial taste; back throat feel Container-22 oz. bottle Alc#-6.8% Malts: Specialty 2-row, Rye ale, Canada wheat malt, Best malt Vienna Hops: Warrior, Northern brewer, Palisade, Crystal, Fuggle, US Golding, Cascade Dry Hop: Cascade, Crystal, Amarillo Aftertaste-Pleasant; I'll remember it!!! Rating-8
Final Thought-I remember trying some other Schmaltz products a while back and I am still impressed.
Mike Komaroff, BeerBaron

Kirkland Pale Ale

2009-10-15T07:17:00.000-07:00

A trip to costco does not often bring the opportunity to try four new contract brewed beers under the flagship Kirkland brand for $18.99 per case. Utica Club is the Contract brewer out of Utica, New York. The one I will rate tonight is their pale ale brewed with Yakima Valley (Wash.) hops.
Kirkland Pale Ale: Color-Golden Nose-Hoppy First taste-Hops then total fast fade Observations-Maintains some balance but falters Fizziness-Frothy head; few active bubbles Cost-$.79 Where brewed? Utica, NY Container-12 oz. bottle Alc.#-5.4% Aftertaste-Not much stamina; slight remaining taste Rating-6.25
Final Thought-Average Pale Ale; Nothing More!!!
Mike Komaroff, BeerBaron

Magic Hat Lucky Kat (IPA)

2009-10-15T07:14:00.000-07:00

A quick evaluation of one of the summer collection of Magic Hat brews purchased last month at West Chester, Pa. on our Delaware trip bringing Bryce back to college.
Magic Hat Lucky Kat: Color-Orange red cloudy Nose-Hoppy, pleasant Fizziness-Multiple active bubbles Head-Foamy, ample First taste-Strong blast of hoppiness Observations-Slight grapefruit Cost-$.83 (Case price*$19.99) Alc.-5.8% Brewed-So. Burlington, Vt. Aftertaste-Lasting hop character Rating-7.75
Mike Komaroff
BeerBaron

Magic Hat Odd Notion Summer '09

2009-10-15T07:11:00.000-07:00

BeerBaron back with you doing an individual tasting from the Magic Hat summer collection procured from West Chester, Pa. on my trip to Delaware with Bryce and Audrey. Each seasonal assortment has an odd notion selection: this one is a Belgian type ale.
Magic Hat Odd Notion: Malts: Pale Hops: Apollo Gravity: 15.5 Alc.%-5.9 IBU(Bitterness)-17 Yeast: Belgian Ale Color: Golden Very drinkable and light. Surprise ingredient is Belgian candy sugar. Mildly carbonated. Rating-7.5
Mike Komaroff
BeerBaron

Thumbnail Beer Evaluation

2009-10-15T07:09:00.000-07:00

Since summer has hit I have curtailed my full scale beer tasting except for occasions when Gary & Rita join for IPA festivities. Tonight I will do an abbreviated test of a German pilsner Konig Pilsner using the Czech Republic's famous Pilsner Urquell as my foundation brew. This German beer as well as all others are subject to the Purity Law (Reinheitsgebot) originating in 1516. The Konig has a harder edge in taste than its' Czech cousin. It is not as memorable but does carry the day with a pleasant feel and nice aftertaste. I purchased a 4-pack of 500 ml. cans for $5 at Eagle provisions in my neighborhood. I do recommend this pilsner to all discriminating beer fans!!!
BeerBaron

Brooklyn Lager 12 oz. bottle

2009-10-15T07:06:00.000-07:00

Before Bryce left for UDel to finish her final exams she told me to go to her car. She said I would find beer in a Party City bag in her trunk. I cannot remember leaving any beer there but did find seven Brooklyn Lager (alc #5.2%) there. My first task was to check for dates to see if the beer was drinkable. Usually this beer used notches on the label somewhere to designate when the beer is in its' most desirable state. When my careful label check showed nothing I perused the sides of the bottle finding a Best Before Aug. 2009 below the neck. You learn something new all the time. Keep those beer bottles on your lips and enjoy!!!
Skol,
"THE BEER BARON"

Intriguing IPA's

2009-10-15T06:57:00.000-07:00

Craig and Jacqueline are visiting us while Audrey is at mema's in Florida.
1)Acme California IPA (Ft.Bragg, Cal.): Alc.6.5% Cloudy; citrusy; slight bitter bite; well balanced; 55 IBU; smoothness Craig-8 Mike-7.75 Avg.-7.875 http://www.northcoastbrewing.com/beer-AcmeIPA.htm
2)Mad Hatter IPA (Holland, Mich.): Alc.5.8% Cloudy; strong hoppy nose; citrusy; heavy hops taste; not bitter; piney tang; lacks smoothness Craig-7.75 Mike-7.5 Avg.-7.625 http://newhollandbrew.com/corp/beer/mainstays
3)Titan IPA (Denver,Col.): Alc.6.8% Clear; mild hops; sharp; tangy; fades; has flavor Craig-7 Mike-7 Avg.-7 http://www.greatdivide.com/#/beer
4)Indica IPA (Eureka, Cal.): Alc.6.5% Cloudy; hoppy nose; citrusy; not bitter; drinkable Craig-7.5 Mike-7 Avg.-7.375 http://www.lostcoast.com/
5)Magic Hat Roxy Rolles (So. Burlington, Vt.): Alc.-5.1% Strong burst; flavorful; hoppy Craig-7.5 Mike-7 Avg.-7.25 http://www.magichat.net/
All in all a very fine evening of hoppy IPA's!!!
Signed: Craig Brodsky & Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Dogfish Head 120 Minute IPA

2009-03-31T07:29:00.000-07:00

Dogfish Head of Milton, Delaware brews three IPA ales (60, 90, & 120 Min.) I've sampled the 60 and 90 minute examples; tonight we will be trying the 120 minute brew. (Click beer for beer's website.)
Dogfish Head 120 Minute: Intense hoppiness; citrus nose; extremely cloudy; intense sweetness; strong alcohol masked well; balanced; "Sip at your own risk"; Much better cold; 120 IBU; Alc.18-21% Craig-7.25 Mike-8 Avg.-7.625
Craig Brodsky & Mike Komaroff Beer Baron

India Pale Ale Intensified

2009-03-31T07:04:00.000-07:00

My nephew Craig and his wife Jackie are here for a visit from Durham, NC. Craig will be the resident beer impresario at this tasting with the BeerBaron assuming only backup status. Let's begin to explore the tantalizing world of IPA's!!! (Click beer name for beer's website.)

1)Cottonwood Endo (Mooresville, NC): 5.9%alc. Hoppy nose; Cloudy w/ floating sediment; apricot flavor; crisp; drinkable; smoothness; slight aftertaste Craig-6.5 Mike-7.25 Avg.-6.875

2)Hop Ottin' IPA (Mendocino, Cal.): 7.0%alc. Very hoppy nose; clear; grapefruity; bitter bite; smooths out; full mouth; moose on bottle Craig-7.5 Mike-7.75 Avg.-7.625

3)White Hawk IPA (Saratoga Springs, NY): 7.0%alc. Slight hop nose; clear; fast taste burst; not hoppy; flattens out; bitter; tangy aftertaste Craig-6.25 Mike-6.5 Avg.6.375

4)Rocky Mountain IPA (Ft. Collins, Col.): 6.2%alc. Cloudy; fruit apricot nose; strong taste; big bite; fast fade; carmel feel; slight bitterness; elephant on label Craig-7.5 Mike-7.0 Avg.7.25

5)Smuttynose IPA (Portsmouth, NH): 5.6%alc. Frothy head; cloudy; citrusy nose; strong apricot; fruit lingers; not bitter; harbor seal on label Craig-7.5 Mike-7.5 Avg.7.5

6)Wolaver's IPA (Middlebury, Vt.): 55IBU(Int'l Bitter Rating) Organic since 1997; not bitter; unfiltered; rustic Craig-6.75 Mike-6.25 Avg.6.5

Final Thought-I had never seen any of Craig's entries (1-4); all in all the IPA's were interesting and satisfying!!!

Craig Brodsky - Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Amber Lagers

2009-03-18T09:38:00.000-07:00

Time for another lager beer tasting session as we approach the first day of spring.
Fisherman's Brew: Color-Cloudy orange amber Nose-Malty First taste-Full mouth; pleasant Observations-Well balanced Fizziness-Mild head; light carbonation Where brewed? Gloucester, Mass. Cost-$.83 Saying-"To the Sailors of the N. Atlantic" Style-Amber lager Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Back throat Rating-7.5
Saranac Season's Best (late '08): Color-Clear orange amber Nose-Malty First taste-Slight harshness Observations-Mellows out Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.16 Saying-"Spirit of Adirondacks" Style-Nut brown lager Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Caramel Rating-7
Final thought-Saranac consistent but outpointed by the Fisherman's Brew!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Lager To the Nth Degree

2009-03-16T08:19:00.000-07:00

As we were in Manhattan a trip to Trader Joe's found a couple of beers from Monroe, Wisconsin. I chose to try the lager (6.2%alc.) over the pilsner.
Harp Lager: Color-Golden Nose-Of grain First taste-Foreign taste Observations-Smooth feel Fizziness-Frothy head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Dublin, Ireland Cost-$1.21 Saying-"From the brewers of Guinness" Style-Imported lager Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Nice Rating-7.25
Simpler Times Lager: Color-Yellow golden Nose-Sweet First taste-Fast burst; quick fade Observations-Not well balanced Fizziness-Mild head; many active bubbles Where Brewed? Monroe, Wis. Cost-$.66 Saying-"From Simpler Times" Style-High alcohol lager Container-12 oz. can Aftertaste-Mildness Rating-6
Final Thought-Alcohol bang for the buck in Simpler Times; Harp better for an imported price!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Hoppy Ales

2009-03-16T08:16:00.000-07:00

In my continuing search for "hoppiness" I will try an amber ale as well as a pale ale.
Flying Dog Classic: Color-Orange amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Quick taste; hops on throat Observations-Balanced Fizziness-Mild head; few active bubbles Where Brewed? Frederick, Md. Cost-$.83 Saying-"Doggie style" Style-Pale ale Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Classy Rating-7.5
Magic Hat Roxy Rolles: Color-Red amber Nose-Grapefruity First taste-Intense Observations-Almost too hoppy? Fizziness-Frothy head; very few bubbles Where brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Cost-$.91 Saying-Motor cyclist in black on label Style-Amber ale Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Hops linger Rating-7.25
Final thought-Roxy Rolles can be tested among the IPA's; Flying Dog has more hops than most pale ales and finishes well!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Brandishing Brown Ales

2009-03-09T08:25:00.000-07:00

The snow has begun to melt as springlike temperatures have hit the NYC area. Weekend weather for Bryce's (20) birthday weekend are expected in the 60's. This brings us to another session quaffing brown ale with all the gusto I can muster!!!
Saranac India Brown Ale: Color-Orange brown Nose-Clean First taste-Sharp; full mouth Observations-Nice; pleasant taste Fizziness-Mild head; active bubbles Where brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.16 Saying-"Spirit of Adirondacks" Style-India style brown ale Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Decent Rating-7.25
Weyerbacher Winter Ale: Color-Yellow brown Nose-Caramel First taste-Quick taste; fast fade Observations-Flattens out Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where brewed? Easton, Pa. Cost-$.76 Saying-Snowmen on Label Style-Winter Ale Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Molasses like Rating-6.25
Final thought-Saranac decidedly better!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Perpetually

2009-03-05T08:34:00.000-08:00

With a major Nor'easter snowstorm bearing down on the Northeast, I will taste 1 previously tested pale ale in one of my repeat tastings.
Flying Dog Classic: Color-Orange amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Grapefruit Observations-Nicely balanced Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where brewed? Frederick, Maryland Cost-$.83 Saying-"Doggie Style" Aftertaste-Memorable Rating-7.5
Wolaver's: Color-Orange amber Nose-Clean First taste-Back throat Observations-Fast fade of taste Fizziness-Mild head; light carbonation Where Brewed? Middlebury, Vt. Cost-$.83Saying-Organic ingredients Aftertaste-Earthy Rating-6.5
Final Thoughts-Flying Dog much more like what i think pale ale should be. Wolaver not positive!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Wheat Ale On Your Way

2009-03-05T08:32:00.000-08:00

Following a walk with Audrey on the avenue, I am home doing a tasting of wheat type brews.
Ayinger Brau-Weisse: Color-Cloudy yellow golden Nose-Tangy First taste-Quick burst; fast fade Observations-Smooths out but weird taste Where brewed? Aying, Germany Cost-$.83Saying-"Brau von Aying" Container-11.2 oz. bottle Fizziness-Frothy foam; few bubbles Aftertaste-Strange Rating-6.5
Magic Hat Circus Boy: Color-Cloudy golden Nose-Sweet First taste-Nice first feel Observations-Pleasant Where Brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Cost-$.83 Saying-"The Hefeweizen" Container-12 oz. bottle Fizziness-Rim head; no bubbles Aftertaste-Positive Rating-7.75
Final Thought-Circus Boy much tastier and well balanced!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Redbridge Gluten-Free (Anheuser Busch)

2009-03-05T08:28:00.000-08:00

Here is my first encounter with gluten free beer brewed with sorghum instead of wheat:
Redbridge: Color-Orange amber Nose-Slight First taste-Fast burst; flattens out Observations-Pleasant taste Fizziness-No head; many active bubbles Cost-$.83 Style-Gluten free (Brewed with water, sorghum, hops, & yeast) Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste- Of citrus Rating-6.75
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Croatian Beer

2009-03-05T08:24:00.000-08:00

Following a dinner out in lower Manhattan with 5 Boro Phil (Beach Club Cabana Mate), I am checking out Karlovacko Pivo, a Croatian beer for the second time (followup).
Karlovacko Pivo: Color-Clear golden Nose-Fresh First taste-Full mouth; good taste Observations-Well balanced Fizziness-Slight head; bubbles Where Brewed? Karlovacko, Croatia (founded in 1854) Cost-$.83 Container-11.15 ozs. Aftertaste-European feel Rating-8
Final Thought-Representative Europa Beer
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pilsner Power

2009-02-25T07:43:00.000-08:00

I will rate and hopefully enjoy two domestic Pilsners as I watch the 81st Academy Awards being presented.
Lion's Head Deluxe: Color-Yellow golden Nose-Of grain First taste-Strong taste; fast fade Observations-Back throat feel Fizziness-Mild head; bubbles Where brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Saying-The Best Head in Town Cost-$.83 Aftertaste-Some Rating-7
Saranac Bohemian: Color-Golden Nose-Of grain First taste-Strong taste; fades away Observations-Pleasant taste left Fizziness-Frothy head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Saying-The Spirit of the Adirondacks Aftertaste-Slight Rating-6.75
Final Thought-Close Nod to LionsHead in an almost even tilt.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Ales on Wednesday

2009-02-19T09:00:00.000-08:00

A cold rain has hit the New York area. I am dedicating this ale tasting to the birth of my new cousin Nathan Jon Somma son of Nicole and Jon.
Magic Hat Hocus Pocus: Color-Golden Nose-Citrus First taste-Full mouth; some flavor Observations-Pleasant Where Brewed? So. Burlington, VT. Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Cost-$.84 Style-Summer ale Saying-Honey bee on label Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Complex Rating-6.75
Saranac E.S.B.(Extra Special Bitter): Color-Orange amber Nose-Cinnamon; malty First taste-Full mouth; flavorful Observations-Very drinkable Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Cost-$1.16 Style-Special bitter Saying-Spirit 0f Adirondacks Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Slightly bitter Rating-7.50
Final Thought-"All's Well that Ales Well."

Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Vermont's Amber Ale Alternatives

2009-02-16T08:29:00.000-08:00

Approaching Presidents Day and Audrey's week off following it, I am testing 2 Vermont amber ales. I expect a good showing by both as I am very familiar with both brewers.
Magic Hat Roxy Rolles: Color-Dark red amber Nose-Very hoppy First taste-Full mouth; solid Observations-Refreshing; hop emphasized Where Brewed?So. Burlington, VT. Fizziness-Frothy; few active bubbles Saying-Ingredients harmonize chemically Style-Hoppy amber ale Alc#-5.1% Aftertaste-Revived grapefruit Rating-7.75
Otter Creek Copper Ale: Color-Orange amber Nose-Sweet vinegar First Taste-Bitter full mouth Observations-Not positive taste Where Brewed? Middlebury, VT. Fizziness-Medium head; active bubbles Saying-Small batch craft organic brewer Style-Medium bodied amber ale Aftertaste-Bitterness personified Rating-7.25
Final Thought-Roxy Rolles lost a 1/4 point for its' hoppiness being too intense; Otter Creek ale gained 1/4 point for leveling off from total bitterness!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Parade

2009-02-16T08:23:00.000-08:00

Following some hours volunteering at MS51 for a drama event, I am home and ready for some mild hoppiness on my BeerBaron palate.
Flying Dog "Doggie Style": Classic Pale Ale Color-Amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Tangy; on tongue Observations-Tasty; balanced Where Brewed? Frederick, Md. Fizziness-Mild head; many active bubbles Cost-$.83 Style-Pale Ale Saying-Hunter S. Thompson-"Good people drink good beer." Alcohol#-5.5% Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Consistent Rating-7.75
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale: Color-Golden amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Full mouth Observations-Fades; some taste remains Where Brewed? Chico, Cal. Cost-$.83 Style-Pale Ale Alcohol#-5.6% Container-12 oz. bottle Saying-Bottle conditioned Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Aftertaste-Still good Rating-7.5
Final Thought-Very close battle in the pale ale category!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Winter Ale (Wow!!!)

2009-02-11T13:32:00.000-08:00

A day before my 58th birthday I will compare 2 domestic winter ales on a 60 degree day in mid-February!!!
Red Hook Winter Hook: Color-Reddish orange Nose-Fresh; slightly sweet First taste-Full mouth Observations-Nice taste Where Brewed? Portsmouth, NH Fizziness-Mild head; active bubbles Cost-$.83 Alc#-5.9% Aftertaste-Wonderful Rating-8.5
Weyerbacher Winter Ale: Color-Reddish brown Nose-Chocolate First taste-Cloaked sweet taste Observations-Fast fade; not consistent Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Where brewed? Easton, Pa. Cost-$.76 Container-12 oz. bottle Style-Winter Ale Saying-Snowmen on Label Aftertaste-Same taste as before Rating-6.25
Final Thought-Red Hook one of the "best" winter ales I've ever taste!!! Weyerbacher more like a porter; did not have the "panache" a quality winter ale should!!!
Mike Komaroff, BeerBaron

Bryce Return UDel Tasting

2009-02-10T07:54:00.000-08:00

Bryce has been here since Dec.16 on her inter-session break. She drove back to Delaware last night; I'm going to wet my whistle with some European beers from brewing nations.
Karlovacko Beer (1854): Color-Golden yellow Nose-Of grain First taste-Back throat; hard taste Observations-Holds its own Fizziness-Mild head; many active bubbles Where Brewed? Karlovack, Croatia Cost-$.83 Container-11.15 fl. ozs. Aftertaste-Very European feel Rating-7.25
Krusovice Imperial Lager: Color-Amber Nose-Mild scent First taste-Full mouth; even flavor Observations-Lasting taste Fizziness-Rim head; some bubbles Where brewed? Krusovice, Czech Republic Cost-Gift Container-16.9 fl. ozs. Aftertaste-Emblematic of "Czech" brews Rating-7.5
Final Thought-Both are exemplary examples of European lagers; very close; edge to Krusovice!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pumpkin Ale Powwow

2009-02-09T07:48:00.000-08:00

As winter temperatures seem to be moderating here, I will try some pumpkin ales with Audrey.
Jack's Pumpkin Ale (w/spices): Color-Clear orange amber Nose-Spicy First taste-Quick taste; quicker fade Observations-Not much going on Fizziness-Foamy head; few bubbles Cost-$.83 Where Brewed? St.Louis, Mo. Factoid-From Michelob Collection Aftertaste-Slight Rating-Mike-6.5 Audrey-8 Avg.-7.25
Smuttynose Pumpkin: Color-Clear orange amber Nose-Pumkiny First taste-Nice flavor; lingers Observations-Tasty; slightly bitter Fizziness-Rim head; some carbonation Cost-$1.20 Where Brewed? Portsmouth, NH Factoid-Cuchobino Pumpkin Aftertaste-Full mouth Rating-Mike-7.75 Audrey-6.5 Avg.-7.125
Final Thought-Audrey liked Bud's Pumpkin (w/spices)more; Smuttynose my fave!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Czech Republic Ambrosia

2009-02-09T07:44:00.000-08:00

This tasting took place before our Florida trip; it was among the best I've ever done, but not surprising as the Czech Republic is one of the worlds best brewing nations.
Pilsner Urquell: Color-Clear golden Nose-Slight floral First taste-Full mouth; satisfying Observations-Wonderful; satisfying Fizziness-Rim head; limited carbonation Where Brewed? Plezen, Czech Republic (1869) Cost-Gift Alc#-4.4% Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Remember it!!! Rating-8.5
Staropramen Premium: Color-Clear golden Nose-Slight floral First taste-Quick taste; slight fade Observations-Solid flavor remains Fizziness-Rim head; slight carbonation Where Brewed? Prague, Czech Republic(1842) Cost-$.83 Alc#-5% Container-11.2 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Nice Rating-7.75
Final Thought-Close to full point differential in comparison came down to overall taste and a fine finish!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Revisited

2009-01-29T13:48:00.000-08:00

Tonight I will revisit one of the pale ales I've tried many times before.
Magic Hat No.9: Color-Clear amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Back throat Observations-Nice edge Fizziness-Rim head; active bubbles Where Brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Cost-$.84 Container-12 oz. bottle Style-Pale ale Saying-Not quite pale ale Aftertaste-Still of hops Rating-7.25
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Dark Beers

2009-01-27T07:53:00.000-08:00

Dark beers can have more depth than other beers lighter in color; I'll investigate 2 examples one domestic and one brewed in Mexico.
Saranac Black Forest: Color-Brown w/orange tint Nose-Slightly smoky First taste-Back throat; settles in Observations-Pleasant taste Fizziness-Frothy head; some bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05 Style-Bavarian style Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Solid Rating-7.25
Trader Joe's Dark: Color-Dark amber Nose-Sweet mocha First taste-Full mouth; fades Observations-Taste not my fave; yet it's alright Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Tecate, Mexico Cost-$1.08 Style-Dark premium lager Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-On taste buds; good Rating-6.75
Final Thought-Saranac more impressive; Trader Joe's Dark good too!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Guinness/Harp Black & Tan

2009-01-27T07:51:00.000-08:00

As displayed at the Guinness event I attended 2 years ago, I am mixing black & tan(s) with a metal implement that separates the Guinness forming a split brew with lager at the bottom and stout at the top. The stout taste hits first followed by the lager serving as a "chaser". The Harp tempers the Guinness making a pleasing beverage. The head is classic Guinness; very smooth and delicious. Tonight I am checking out the black & tan as a combined brew; these Irish beers seem to blend well. I would like to try different combinations at a future time. Both products were brewed in Dublin, Ireland. The nose is of the stout, but the lager tones it down.
Witness: Audrey Komaroff
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Red Ales

2009-01-27T07:49:00.000-08:00

After a wonderful lunch courtesy of Restaurant Week at the River Cafe, I am home and anxious to taste two domestic red ales.
Hooker Irish Red Ale: Color-Dark brown; orange highlights Nose-Caramel First taste-Full mouth; fast fade Observations-Taste on flat side Fizziness-Rim head; few active bubbles Where Brewed? Saratoga Springs, NY (CT.) Rating-6
Lagunitas Imperial Red Ale: Color-Reddish orange Nose-Hoppy First taste-Strong hops taste; lingers Observations-Flavor intense Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Where brewed? Petaluma, Sonoma County, California Alc.#-7.2% Rating-7.25
Final Thought-Alcohol level evident in Lagunitas Red; intensity of taste prevented my rating from being higher than 7.25 (which was respectable). Hooker decidedly not as good!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Saranac Vanilla Stout

2009-01-22T10:13:00.000-08:00

Saranac Vanilla Stout: Brewed in Utica, NY Cost-$1.16Color-Black (reddish tint)Nose-Mocha First taste-Full mouth; even balanced taste Observations-Not sweet; very good stout Fizziness-Thick frothy head; carbonated Rating-7.25
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Elysian Night Owl Pumpkin Ale

2009-01-19T10:38:00.000-08:00

As the Arizona Cardinals put the finishing touches on the Eagles 32-25, Audrey and I will evaluate a domestic pumpkin ale:
Elysian Night Owl Pumpkin Ale: Color-Cloudy dark amber Nose-Pumpkin like First taste-Smooth; slight bitterness Observations-Nice taste on palate Fizziness-Nice head; few bubbles Cost-$1.82 Where Brewed? Fort Collins, Colorado Other Ingredients-Nutmeg, cloves, cinnamon, ginger, & allspice Container-22 oz. bottle Style-Pumpkin ale w/spices Alc#-5.9% Factoid-Elysian won Brewpub/Brewmaster at the Great American Beer Festival held in Denver, Colorado 1999, 2003 & 2004 Aftertaste-Pleasing Rating* Audrey-7.5 Mike-7.5 Avg.-7.5
Final thought-Above average!!!
Audrey Komaroff-Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Lager Thursday/Friday

2009-01-19T10:35:00.000-08:00

Audrey and I are watching the movie Zodiac (about the California serial killer) as temps. hover in the single digits with snow still on the ground. I will evaluate 2 domestic lagers now:
1)Labatt Blue: Color-Clear golden Nose-Fresh First taste-Refreshing; fades Observations-Pleasant Fizziness-Rim head; bubbles Where Brewed? Toronto, Ontario, Canada Cost-$1.00 Style-Pilsner Saying-Imported Daily from Canada Aftertaste-Overall smoothness Rating-7.25
2)Smuttynose Portsmouth: Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Malty First taste-Strong; hard taste Observations-Goes back throat Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Where brewed? Portsmouth, NH Cost-$.84 (food co-op) Style-Lager Saying-Fancy buoys on bottle Aftertaste-Harsh Rating-7
Final Thought-Very representative beers in the lager category!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Tuesday!!!

2009-01-15T06:49:00.000-08:00

I will try another 2 domestic pale ales readying myself for the Arctic blast of cold air that will envelope the northeast beginning tomorrow.
1)Wolaver's Pale Ale: Color-Clear amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Full mouth Observations-Slight harshness Fizziness-Frothy head; active bubbles Where Brewed? Middlebury, VT. Cost-$.84(Co-op sale) Container-12 oz. bottle Style-Pale Ale Saying-Certified Organic Aftertaste-Smooth Rating-7.25
2)Magic Hat No.9: Color-Clear amber Nose-Mildly hoppy First taste-Back throat Observations-Consistent Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where Brewed? So. Burlington, VT. Cost-$.84 Container-12 oz. bottle Style-Pale Ale Saying-Not quite pale ale Aftertaste-Can still taste hops Rating-7
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Winter Ale, Dark Ales & Others

2009-01-13T07:24:00.000-08:00

Following a brutal defeat of the Giants by the Eagles 23-11 in a game I attended in the Meadowlands with my nephew Craig, we are back at my house to do our final beer tasting of the weekend. It will encompass all ales and beers that are dark to the visual sense. This is an area of beer which I think is under appreciated!!!
1)Southern Tier Old Man Winter Ale: Clear caramel; sweet molasses nose; ginger taste; remaining spice feel; goes down easy Craig-7.25 Mike-8 Avg.-7.625
2)Smuttynose Old Brown Dog Ale: (5.9% alc.) Mild head; semi-clear brown; nose of light chocolate; porter taste; not much carbonation; taste fades; smooth; goes down easy Craig-7.75 Mike-7.5 Avg.-7.625
3)Magic Hat Notion: (4.2% alc.)Mild head; mahogany cloudy color; non descript nose; semi-bitter taste(watered down), no aftertaste Craig-7 Mike-6.5 Avg.-6.75
4)Saranac India Style Brown Ale: (6% alc.) Clear orange amber; rich aroma; back throat taste; celery or spice feel; taste is maintained Craig-6.5 Mike-7 Avg.-6.75
5)Smuttynose Robust Porter: (5.4% alc.) Nice head; opaque black; burning smoky nose; smoother than expected; coffee taste Craig-6.75 Mike-6.75 Avg.-6.75
6)Yeungling Black & Tan: Frothy head; opaque look with red highlight; Stout smell (not strong); like a thinner stout; charged porter; easy stout(fizzy stout) Craig-6.75 Mike-6.75 Avg.-6.75
7)Guinness Stout Draught (bottle w/ widget): Amazing head; opaque black; stouty rich(clean); smooth; coffee Craig-8.25 Mike-7.25 Avg.-7.75
Signed: Craig Brodsky & Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Belgian, Belgian Style Event

2009-01-10T22:42:00.000-08:00

With a blanket of snow having fallen on the NYC area we will drink ales from Belgium and those brewed in the US with Belgian themes in mind.
1)Malheur #10 Golden Ale (Buggenhour, Belgium):-10% Alc. Very cloudy golden; rich fruity aroma; can taste alcohol(negative); nice medium range; some aftertaste Craig-6.25 Mike-7.25 Avg.-6.75
2)Trappistes Rochefort 6 Ale:- Alc#7.5%-frothy head; sediment; dark brown cloudy; porter type flavor; fades; flattens out Craig-7.25 Mike-7 Avg.-7.125
3)Ommegang Abbey Ale (Cooperstown, NY): Alc#8.5% Frothy; caramel color; Nose of cloves; good positive taste; staying power Craig-7.25 Mike-7.5 Avg.-7.375
4)Hades Belgian Style Ale (Denver, Col.): Alc.#7.3% Golden clear; very few bubbles; spicy aroma; smooth; spicy taste; flavor consistent; refreshing Craig-7.25 Mike-7.75 Avg.-7.50
5)Saranac Belgian Ale (Utica, NY): Cloudy amber; fruity sweet smell; bitterness; fades; spicy Craig-7.25 Mike-6.75 Avg.-7

_____________________________________________
6)Magic Hat Hocus Pocus Summer Ale (So. Burlington, Vt.): Head faded to rim; cloudy golden; floral nose; light; pleasant taste; good finish Craig-7.5 Mike-7 Avg.-7.25
Signed: Craig Brodsky & Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Giants Playoff Weekend Alefest

2009-01-10T22:12:00.000-08:00

A trip to Newark Airport to pick Craig up for the key NFL playoff game Sunday versus the Eagles. We will evaluate five ales of various types this morning.
1) Saranac E.S.B.(Extra Special Bitter): Utica, NY Orange reddish color; malty nose; some active bubbles; earthy sweetness; fast fade;slightly bitter aftertaste; goes down easy Craig-6.75 Mike-7.25 Avg.-7
2) Magic Hat No.9-(So. Burlington, Vt): Cloudy golden; hoppy; fruity; slight head; citrusy; grapefruity; flavor lasting; pleasant aftertaste Craig-7 Mike-7.50 Avg.-7.25
3) Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale-(Portsmouth, NH): Cloudy amber; bitter nose; smoother than expected; celery flavor/ cinnamon taste Craig-6 Mike-5.5 Avg.-5.75
4) Smithwick's(Dublin, Ireland): Clear thick head; root beer color; sweet stout nose; coffee flavor; sweet toffee feel; fades; weird aftertaste(negative) Craig-6 Mike-5.5 Avg.-5.75
5) Saranac Belgian Ale(Utica, NY): Cloudy amber; fruity; pleasant aroma; strong taste; bitter; fades; not great aftertaste Craig-5.75 Mike-6 Avg.-5.875
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Harp Lager

2009-01-10T22:10:00.000-08:00

FLORIDA GATORS 24 Oklahoma Sooners 14 > I dedicate this tasting to my nephew Craig.
Harp Lager: Color-Golden Nose-Of barley First taste-Full mouth Observations-Nice taste Fizziness-Frothy head; fast active bubbles Where Brewed? Dublin, Ireland Cost-$1.27 Style-Lager Saying-Brewed by Guinness Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Tangy Rating-7.5
Final Thought-Above average European lager!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Stout Smack Down

2009-01-08T07:36:00.000-08:00

Here I am again comparing bottled Guinness with a stout (vanilla) from Saranac.
Guinness Draught: Color-Dark brown; red tint Nose-Mocha like First taste-Smooth; on palate Observations-Initial taste fades Fizziness-Creamy; frothy; heavily carbonated Where Brewed? Dublin, Ireland Cost-$1.17 Aftertaste-Some Rating-7.25
Saranac Vanilla: Color-Black Nose-Of vanilla First taste-Strong; full mouth Observations-Nice lasting taste Fizziness-Frothy; can't see bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.16 Aftertaste-Lingering sweetness Rating-7.75
Final thought-Guinness on tap much better than any example in a bottle.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Links are to the beer's webpage.

Lager Add-On

2009-01-07T09:04:00.000-08:00

I will be evaluating Saranac Bohemian Pilsner as part of my new plan to do single tastings as well as comparisons.
Saranac Bohemian Pilsner: Color-Clear golden Nose-Fresh First taste-Strong; fast fade Observations-Pleasant Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Mild head; active bubbles Cost-$1.16 Style-Bohemian pilsner Saying-Spirit of Adirondacks Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Not much Rating-6.5
Final Thought: Not top shelf Saranac but respectable.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

PS. Click on the beer to see the Saranac web page on Bohemian Pilsner

More Ales Already

2009-01-07T09:01:00.000-08:00

We're in the New Year about 2 weeks before Obama is sworn in as our new president. Ales are a great beverage for celebration; so let's quaff a few and rate them as we go.
Magic Hat Notion (Summer '08): Color-Brown; orange red highlights Nose-Chocolate First taste-Porter like Observations-Flat; carbonation not translating well Cost-$.84 Fizziness-Rim head; active bubbles Where Brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Style-English style ale Alcohol #-4.2% Aftertaste-Some; flattened out Rating-6
Yeungling Lord Chesterfield Ale: Color-Golden yellow Nose-Mildly hoppy First taste-Full mouth; quick fade Observations-Sharp; hops taste Cost-$.75 Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Pottsville, Pa. Style-American ale Aftertaste-Strong ale taste remains Rating-6.75
Final Thought: Although both are ales, they are on different ends of the ALE spectrum!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Magic Hat No.9

2009-01-05T06:26:00.000-08:00

As part of my new strategy to rotate my beers better to avoid deteriorating brew, I will do some individual tests.
Magic Hat No.9: Color-Clear amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Back throat Observations-Taste is lasting Fizziness-Frothy head; few bubbles Where Brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Cost-$.84 Container-12 oz. bottle Saying-Not quite pale ale Aftertaste-Hoppiness still evident Rating-7
Happy New Year!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pumpkin Ale Again!!!

2009-01-05T06:24:00.000-08:00

Deja-vu all over again. This is the third time these 2 pumpkin ale foes have met in my competition. Audrey will be both a spectator and participant in today's action.
Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale (Portsmouth, NH): Strong bitter taste; then taste fades; back throat staying pumpkin; Cost-$.91-sale at Park Slope Food Co-op Rating-6.75
Blue Moon Harvest Moon Pumpkin Ale (Golden, CO.): Not as bitter; no aftertaste bitterness; fresh Ratings: Audrey-8 Mike-7.5 Avg.-7.75
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Savoring Stouts?

2009-01-05T06:21:00.000-08:00

Bryce will be observing this tasting of 2 stouts done in my novice series. Jordan will be my guest(novice) taster; he did this on one other occasion. Here goes:
Guinness Stout Draft (Dublin, Ireland): Classic Guinness head; bitter; soy sauce nose; bitter aftertaste; not carbonated in same way as other beers; Salty Jordan-6 Mike-7.5 Avg.-6.75
Saranac Oatmeal Stout (Utica, NY): Bitter; bile like taste; more coarse; not as frothy; soy sauce nose; strong w/ rubbing alcohol feel Jordan-3.5 Mike-6.75 Avg.-5.125
Final Thought-Beer Novice Jordan showed a proclivity for beer tasting; I hope he continues to take part in my events!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Xmas Eve Winter Ale Tasting

2009-01-05T06:18:00.000-08:00

The temps have warmed up to the mid 50's and it suddenly doesn't feel like winter. Of course that is the perfect time to sample 2 New York state winter ales.
Brooklyn Winter Ale: Color-Brown w/ reddish orange highlights Nose-Of caramel First taste-Back throat; intense Observations-Taste recedes Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness Mild head; bubbles Cost-$1.36 Alc#-6.1% Aftertaste-Caramel taste still there Rating-6.5
Southern Tier Old Man Winter Ale: Color-Brown w/ orange hue Nose-Aromatic; clean First taste-Full mouth; keeps coming Observations-Real staying power Where Brewed? Lakewood, NY Fizziness-Frothy head; few bubbles Cost-$1.36 Aftertaste-Strong taste remains Rating-7.75
Final Thought-Old Man Winter Ale from Southern Tier was much more distinctive!!! My revelation was the discovery that all winter ales are also brown ales!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Christmas-Chanukah IPA Tasting

2008-12-22T13:15:00.000-08:00

The holiday season has brought together the usual suspects in the Park Slope environs to renew our India pale ale saga.
1)Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA(De.): Slight bitterness; pleasant; pilsner like; subtle grapefruit; smoothness Gary-7.25 Rita-8 Mike-7.75 Avg.-7.666
2)Magic Hat Roxy Rolles(Vt.): Earthy; subtle grapefruit; pleasant; crispy on tongue Gary-6.75 Rita-7 Mike-7 Avg.-6.91
3)Sierra Nevada Pale Ale(Cal.): Fast grapefruit; quick fade; bitter feel; nice aftertaste Gary-6 Rita-6 Mike-7.25 Avg.-6.416
4)Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale'08(Cal.): Nice crispy; molassy burnt taste; crispness on outset; lasting on tongue; pleasant nice aftertaste; dissipates at end Gary-8 Rita-7 Mike-8 Avg.-7.666
Commentary-Fitting tie for first place!!!
Signed: Gary Sweeney, Rita Renella, Mike Komaroff (BeerBaron)

"Repeat" Pumpkin Ale Tasting

2008-12-22T13:13:00.000-08:00

Almost 2 months to the day (10/23/08) I will again evaluate two pumpkin ales.
Blue Moon Harvest Moon Pumpkin: Color-Clear orange amber Nose-Fruity First taste-Balanced Observations-Decent taste Fizziness-Average head; carbonated Where Brewed? Golden, Colorado (Coor's) Cost-$1.16 Style-Pumpkin ale Saying-6 spices & Crystal malt Aftertaste-Consistent Rating-7.25
Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale: Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Pumkiney First taste-Funky Observations-Still strong tasting Fizziness-Rim head; medium carbonation Where Brewed? Portsmouth, NH Cost-$1.20 Style-Pumpkin ale Saying-Cucurbita Pepo (pumpkin) Aftertaste-Very intense Rating-6.75
Final Thought-B.M. Harvest Moon still the winner!!! Slightly poorer showing by both might be seasonally based!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Lager Legacy

2008-12-17T09:39:00.000-08:00

Unfortunately my football Giants have their hands full playing Dallas on the road; a 20-8 loss has put them in a tough spot with the biggest game of the year next Sunday. A win then, (I will be there) will right the ship; a loss would be devastating and could cause a free fall. A beer taste test is in order this evening:
Trader Joe's Bohemian: Color-Mildly cloudy golden Nose-Fresh; gritty First taste-Strong; taste remains Observations-Taste does fade Where brewed? San Jose, Cal. Fizziness-Mild head; more bubbles Cost-$1.00 Style-Bohemian lager Saying-Resembles Czech Republic lager Container-12 oz. bottle Alcohol %-5% Aftertaste-Not lasting Rating-6.25
Yeungling Lager: Color-Clear amber Nose-Floral First taste-Smoother Observations-Full mouth Where Brewed?Pottsville, Pa. Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Cost-$.75 Style-Lager Saying-US's First Brewery (1829) Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Some; decent Rating-7.25
Final thought-Yeungling flagship beer just outclasses Bohemian style TJ's.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Light Beer Libation

2008-12-17T09:34:00.000-08:00

Generally speaking, I consider light beers to be a step down from their higher caloried brethren. As the BeerBaron I still feel obligated to rate them; here goes!!!
Knight's Head Light: Color-Clear golden Nose-Not distinct First taste-Strong Observations-Back throat Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Cost-$.42 Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Saying-Brewing Refined Aftertaste-Some Rating-5.5
Yeungling Light: Color-Clear amber Nose-Of grain First taste-Flat Observations-Taste a negative Where Brewed? Pottsville, Pa. Cost-$.75 Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Saying-US's oldest brewery (1829) Aftertaste-Not good Rating-4
Final Thought-There must be better light beers than these two.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Prioritized

2008-12-17T09:31:00.000-08:00

In my continuing pale ale profiles I will compare 2 domestic examples.
Knight's Head Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Toned down hoppy Observations-Overall quality not good Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Cost-$.42 Style-Pale ale Container-12 oz. bottle Saying-"Brewing Refined" Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Aftertaste-Some taste remains Rating-6.25
Magic Hat No. 9: Color-Clear golden Nose-Nice; hoppy First taste-Intense; full mouth Observations-Smooth; pleasant taste Where brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Cost-$.84 Style-Almost pale ale Alcohol level-4.6% Container-12 oz. bottle Saying-"Not quite pale ale" Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Aftertaste-Positive Rating-7.5
Final thought-Knight's Head sample may have been compromised by shelf life issues.
Mike Komaroff, BeerBaron

Brown Ales (2 Sessions)

2008-12-17T09:27:00.000-08:00

12/07/08
Otter Creek Raspberry Brown: Color-Brown; yellow tinge Nose-Raspberry First taste-Quick taste; fade Observations-Balances Out Where Brewed? Middlebury, Vt. Fizziness-Rim head Cost-$1.00 Style-Raspberry brown ale Aftertaste-Raspberry on tongue Rating-7.25
Smuttynose Old Brown Dog: Color-Brown; orange hue Nose-Spicy First taste-Sharp; back throat Observations-Nice taste Where Brewed? Portsmouth, NH Fizziness-Rim head Cost-$1.20 Style-Brown ale Aftertaste-Lasting Rating-7.50

12/08/08
Saranac Brown Ale: Color-Orange brown Nose-Fresh caramel First taste-Good first taste Observations-Smoothness Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Frothy head; bubbles Cost-$1.06 Style-Brown ale Aftertaste-Nice finish Rating-8.25
Final Thought-In this two day comparative test, Saranac was the clear winner!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Prohibition Repeal (1933) Trader Joe's Beer Blast

2008-12-17T09:24:00.000-08:00

We have gotten to Friday and a key day in the drinkers' historical database. Prohibition of alcoholic beverages pervaded our nation from 1919-1933. I celebrate the 75th anniversary by testing two Trader Joe products one foreign the other domestic.
Trader Joe's Dark: Color-Brown orange hue Nose-Caramel First taste-Back throat Observations-Tastes alright Fizziness-Foamy head; bubbles Where Brewed? Mexico Cost-$1.08 Aftertaste-Smooth Rating-6.5
Trader Joe's Bock: Color-Cloudy dark golden Nose-Funky First taste-Strong on tongue Observations-Weird follow through Fizziness-Mild head; little bubbles Where Brewed? Chico, Cal. Cost-$1.00 Aftertaste-Not pleasant Rating-5.75
Final Thought-Individual Beers!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

"Previous" Black & Tan's

2008-12-01T07:28:00.000-08:00

Following a sumptuous Thanksgiving celebration at my cousin's house in Scarsdale, we are hanging out at home with my mom; here through next Wednesday. I am doing a repeat of a previous test expecting similar results.
Saranac B&T (Stout & Lager): Color-Orange hue brown Nose-Malty First taste-Full mouth Observations-Nice Balance Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05 Aftertaste-Smooth Rating-7.25
Yeungling B&T (Porter & Premium): Color-Red Tint Brown Nose-Of caramel First taste-Strong; flattens out Observations-Tastes good; fades out Where Brewed? Pottsville, Pa. Cost-$.75 Aftertaste-Backthroat Rating-6.5
Final Thought-Black & Tan's-Good ones!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Ales Are Alive

2008-12-01T07:26:00.000-08:00

Thanksgiving evening following a day of family gathering and eating at my cousin's house in Scarsdale. Ales come in many taste patterns and types.
Magic Hat Notion (Summer '08): Color-Orange tinted brown Nose-Of maple; syrup smell First taste-Burnt taste Observations-Nice flavor; balanced Cost-84 cents; Alc.#4.2% Fizziness-Rim head; bubbles Where Brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Saying-Chaotic Chemistry, Humble Patience, & Blind Faith Ingredients-Components of English Ale Aftertaste-Like a "Porter" Ale Rating-7.5
Yeungling Lord Chesterfield: Color-Golden yellow Nose-Of grain First taste-Strong; fast fade Observations-Good ale highlights Cost-75 cents Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where brewed? Pottsville, Pa. Saying-First US Brewery(1829) Ingredients-An American Ale Aftertaste-Full mouth Rating-7
Final Thought-2 Different classes of ale. Both satisfied!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Wheat (Weisse) Beer

2008-12-01T07:24:00.000-08:00

Audrey is at PS1 a Sunset Park elementary school recruiting students for next fall's 6th grade class. I will again encounter the world of wheat beers (originally developed in Germany) with 2 domestic examples.
Brooklyn: Color-Cloudy golden Nose-Of cloves First taste-Full mouth, intense Observations-Sharp; not refreshing Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Where brewed-Utica, NY(Kegs brewed in Brooklyn) Cost-$1.34 Process-Contains yeast Saying-"Brewed in New York Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Back throat Rating-6.25
Magic Hat Circus Boy: Color-Clear yellow Nose-Fruity First taste-Quick taste; fast fade Observations-Levels out Fizziness-Frothy; few bubbles Where brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Cost-$.84 Process-Is Filtered Saying-"The Hefeweizen" Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Some taste stays Rating-7
Final Thought-Not my favorite style; 2 representative examples!!! .
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Thanksgiving IPA Tasting

2008-12-01T07:17:00.000-08:00

The BeerBaron, the Aleman, and the Icegirl are together again in Riverdale for another in our series of IPA quaffings.
1)Hazed & Infused (dry hopped ale) Colorado: grapefruit; dissipates as crispy fades; different bitter at end; caramel burnt taste stays Gary-6 Mike-7 Rita-5.5 Avg.-6.16
2)Stone IPA-California: real grapefruit; full bite; well balanced Gary-7 Mike-8 Rita-6.5 Avg.-7.16
3)Victory Hop Devil IPA-Pa.: very bitter; big grapefruit explosion at first; crispy on back of tongue; burnt bitter Gary-7.75 Mike-7.5 Rita-7 Avg.-7.41
{Lunch Break}
4)Smuttynose IPA-NH: very bitter(lemon seed); bitter; hoppy; not grapefruity; full bodied; rounded Gary-8.25 Mike-7.75 Rita-6 Avg.-7.33
5)Saranac IPA-NY: crispy; then dissipates; aftertaste hot in mouth (sometimes evocative of higher alcohol content); bitter not grapefruit or lemon Gary-7.5 Mike-7.5 Rita-6.5 Avg.-7.16
Signed-Gary J. Sweeney, Mike Komaroff, & Rita Renella

Pale Ale Permutations

2008-12-01T07:15:00.000-08:00

Audrey is giving Maxine a break in Florida by visiting her mom in the re-hab recovering from shoulder replacement surgery. I will do another in my series of pale tastings pitting 2 domestics ones.
Magic Hat No.9: Color-Cloudy golden Nose-Strongly hoppy First taste-Full mouth Observations-Nice taste Where brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Fizziness-Medium head; active bubbles Cost-$.84(Discounted case price) Style-Almost pale ale Saying-Not quite pale ale Alcohol-4.6% Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Some Rating-7.25
Troeg's: Color-Clear yellowish Nose-Pleasant hoppy First taste-Slight grapefruit Observations-Well balanced Fizziness-Mild head; few bubbles Cost-$1.36 Style-Pale ale Saying-Independent Craft brewery Alcohol-5.4% Container-12 oz. Aftertaste-Smooth; tasty Rating-7.5
Final thought-Both very good pale ale types!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Clive Barnes Memorial (Dead at 81) Lager Lunacy

2008-11-19T12:38:00.000-08:00

We mourn Clive Barnes NY Times theater critic dead at age 81 on my mother Rhoda's birthday. One Canadian lager (a pilsner) will take on two domestic lagers; one is the king of beers, and the other from Trader Joe's.
Budweiser: Color-Clear golden Nose-Of grain First taste-Strong Observations-Fast fade Where Brewed? St. Louis, Mo. Fizziness-Foamy; lots of bubbles Cost-$.63 Aftertaste-Not much Rating-5.5
LaBatt's: Color-Clear golden Nose-Funky strange First taste-Nice taste Observations-Smooth; refreshing Where Brewed? Toronto, Canada Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Cost-$1.00 Aftertaste-Full mouth Rating-7.25
Trader Joe's Bohemian: Color-Slightly cloudy golden Nose-Weird First taste-Back throat Observations-Unusual flavor Where Brewed? San Jose, Cal. Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Cost-$1.00 Aftertaste-Still different Rating-6.75
Final Thought-LaBatt very good; Trader Joe's OK; Bud innocuous
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Potential

2008-11-18T11:13:00.000-08:00

Back from a weekend trip to UDel and Bryce, it is a great time to continue my pale ale revues. Tonight I will compare two ales from Vermont; let the evaluating begin!!!
Magic Hat No. 9: Color-Dark yellowish Nose-Heavy hops First taste-Smooth; tangy Observations-Taste remains Fizziness-Foamy head; many bubbles Cost-$.84(Variety Show Pack purchased West Chester, Pa.) Where Brewed? So. Burlington, Vt. Saying-"Essence of Apricot" Aftertaste-Can taste hint of apricot Rating-7.5
Wolaver Pale Ale: Color-Orange amber Nose-Caramel like First taste-Strong; back throat Observations-Fleeting taste; still some Fizziness-Rim head; some carbonation Cost-$1.31 Where Brewed? Middlebury, Vt. Saying-"Certified Organic" Aftertaste-Remainder has some depth Rating-6.75
Final Thought-No. 9 very good pale ale!!!
Mike Komaroff, BeerBaron

Punctuating Pale Ale

2008-11-18T11:11:00.000-08:00

This is another in my series of pale ale tastings; more will follow as this is an area of ale that I have a strong fondness for. Today upstate NY's Saranac (FX Matt Brewing) will take on a New England pale ale from Smuttynose (Shoal's).
Saranac: Color-Clear reddish amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Smooth; tasty Observations-Well Balanced Fizziness-Nice head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05 Saying-"Spirit of the Adirindacks" Aftertaste-Solid Rating-7.75
Smuttynose Shoal's: Color-Cloudy orange amber Nose-Not distinct First taste-Strong; back throat Observations-Quick fade; taste remains Fizziness-Foamy head; no bubbles Cost-$1.20 Saying-"Home of Smuttynose Island" Aftertaste-Strange; weird Rating-7
Final Thought-Saranac one of the best pale ales I've ever sampled. Smuttynose Shoal's a representative pale ale!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

German Beers

2008-11-10T09:30:00.000-08:00

I'm home nursing a cold looking forward to a get together tomorrow with Rita & Gary in Windsor Heights(the new name for our neighborhood). All German beers are brewed under regulations of the Reinheitsgebot (only barley (or wheat), hops and water) a law passed in 1516. The Czech Republic also adheres to these regulations.
St. Pauli Girl Color: Golden Nose-Of grain First taste-Full mouth Observations-Smooth Fizziness-Light head; many active bubbles Cost-$1.00 Style-Lager Where Brewed? Bremen, Germany Aftertaste-Quality lasts Rating-7.5
Warsteiner: Color-Golden Nose-Sweet First taste-Good first taste Observations-Flattens out Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Cost-$.96.5 Style-Pilsner Where Brewed? Warsteiner, Germany Aftertaste-Some taste remains Rating-6.75
Final Thought-St. Pauli Girl better!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Inside the Pale (Ale)

2008-11-10T06:54:00.000-08:00

After going to the Chocolate Show on the Westside piers we are home. Following dinner I am doing an ale tasting while awaiting the onset of the Giants-Eagles tilt in Philadelphia. Three of our familiar pale ales will do battle all of them domestic.
Knight's Head Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy dark orange Nose-Of hops First taste-Strong; hoppy Observations-Some lasting flavor Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Cost-$.42 Saying-"Brewing Refined" Aftertaste-Strong taste remains Rating-6.75
Porkslap (Farmhouse) Pale Ale: Color-Clear dark amber Nose-Funky First taste-Piercing; weird observations-Not positive Where Brewed? Garrattsville, NY Cost-$1.11 Saying-"All Malt" Aftertsate-Some; not great Rating-5.75
Smuttynose (Shoal's Pale Ale): Color-Cloudy dark amber Nose-Weird Observations-Interestingly good Where Brewed? Portsmouth, NH Cost-$1.20 Saying-"Smuttynose Island" Aftertaste-Lasting taste Rating-7
Final Thought-Knight's Head Bargain Choice (When any beer/ale can be purchased for $.42 and be good/very good it is a wonderful buy!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Post Obama Victory IPA Revelation Ale Tasting

2008-11-10T06:50:00.000-08:00

We have reconvened the regular group at the brownstone of the BeerBaron in Greenwood Heights in Brooklyn. It is only four days since the historic election of Barack Obama as President. We are celebrating this event with an IPA tasting today.
1) Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA: (Del.) Very grapefruity; you can smell the hops; crispy; dissipates; still smooth; hint of lemon off grapefruit taste; refreshing Gary-7.25 Rita-7 Mike-7.75 Avg.-7.333
2) Saranac IPA: (NY) Nice nose; initial hoppy; then dissipates; burst then bitterness on back of throat; floral leftover aftertaste that seems soapy (not a Plus) Gary-6 Rita-5 Mike-7 Avg.-6
3) Wolaver IPA: (Vt.) Hint of burnt molasses; bitter hoppy; earthy taste; unpleasant after taste Gary-7 Rita-4 Mike-5.5 Avg.-5.5
4) SmuttyNose IPA: (NH) Hoppy nose; very grapefruit; very hoppy; hint of molasses; lingering sheer grapefruit after taste; ending bitterness Gary-7.75 Rita-6.5 Mike-7.5 Avg.-7.25
Very successful tasting followed by lunch at the Park Slope Ale House!!!
Signed: Gary J. Sweeney, Rita Renella & Mike Komaroff (BeerBaron)

Lay it On: The Lagers

2008-11-06T08:11:00.000-08:00

Election eve finds us awaiting the election of Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois. If the polls are correct we are less than 24 hours away from taking over the White House from Bush and his cohorts. Letting lagers quench my thirst as I rate is tonight's beer game plan. Saranac's Adirondack Lager will take on Yeungling Lager. Onward and upward:
Saranac Adirondack Lager: Color-Amber Nose-Of grain First taste-Strong; flavorful Observations-Good smoothness Fizziness-Rim head; bubbles Where brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05 Style-Lager Saying-"The Spirit of the Adirondacks" Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Lasting Rating-7.5
Yeungling Lager: Color-Amber Nose-Exotic First taste-Back throat Observations-Some taste on tongue Fizziness-Rim head; not heavy carbonation Where Brewed? Pottsville, Pa. Cost-65 cents Style-Lager Saying-America's Oldest Brewery (1829) Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Pleasant Rating-7.5
Final Thought- Saranac the WIN; Yeungling bargain special!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Parade(Session 2 of 2)

2008-11-03T08:15:00.000-08:00

Election day beckons as we enter the month of November; I'll finish off this Pale ale extravaganza with my last 2 selections all having been tasted before. I'll reiterate that more raw numbers will allow the averages to help me formulate conclusions about all the categories tested.
Knight's Head Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Full mouth; fade; then hops Observations-Mostly balanced Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Cost-$.42 Saying-"Brewing Refined" Aftertaste-Still hops Rating-6.75
Pass Time Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy orange amber Nose-Fresh (Audrey) First taste-Quick taste; flattens out Observations-Not memorable Fizziness-Frothy head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Boulder, Col. Cost-$.79 (Pioneer Super Market -W.74th & Columbus Ave.) Saying-Colorado's 1st Micro-Brewery Aftertaste-Pass on this one Rating-6
Final Thought-Possible shelf life problem with Pass Time; Was definitely better when tasted during the spring and summer!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Parade(Part 1 of 2)

2008-10-31T14:58:00.000-07:00

This will be a double pale ale tasting with repeats of previously tasted items. It is part of my process of creating a large enough sample so averages will dictate results.
Saranac Pale Ale: Color-Clear orange amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Nice flavor burst Fizziness-Frothy head; active steady bubbles. Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05 Saying-"The Spirit of the Adirondacks" Aftertaste-Lasting Rating-7.75
Smuttynose Shoal's Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy amber orange Nose-Sharp First taste-Strong piercing taste Observations-Overpowering Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Portsmouth, NH Cost-$1.20 Saying-Samuel Haley House on Smuttynose Island Aftertaste-Flattens out Rating-7
After thought-Saranac a Winner!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Ales of Brown

2008-10-28T07:10:00.000-07:00

As the Phils-Rays strut through the rain in Philly trying to get Game 5 of the World Series in (it was ultimately suspended), I dedicate this ale tasting to my mother in law Frieda who is recovering from abdominal surgery. The Saranac Brown Ale (recently rated at Mike Kagan's apartment) will take on Smuttynose's version Old Brown Dog Ale.
Smuttynose: Color-Orange tinted brown Nose-Chocolate caramel First taste-Back throat; tangy Observations-Smooth but flattens out Fizziness-Rim head; carbonation Where Brewed? Portsmouth, NH Cost-$1.20(12 pack at my food co-op) Container-12 oz. Bottle Style-Brown Ale Saying-Picture on label of Olive(Smuutynose's brown dog) Aftertaste-Full throttle good Rating-7.5
Saranac Brown Ale: Color-Orange tinted brown Nose-Stronger caramel First taste-Full mouth; lasting Observations-Marvelous(Billy Crystal) Flavor Fizziness-Frothy head; carbonation Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05(Adirondack Trail Mix 6 pack at Fairway-Red Hook) Container-12 oz. Bottle Style-Brown Ale Saying-"The Spirit of the Adirondacks" Aftertaste-Almost perfection Rating-8.5
Final Thought-Saranac improved a half a point since Kagan (gave it a 9) tasting; Old Brown Dog representative enough!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Seasonal Pumpkin Ale

2008-10-27T07:42:00.000-07:00

Audrey is still in Florida with her mom recuperating from shoulder replacement surgery. With Halloween approaching I've already purchased pumpkin seed coffee from Fairway. Tonight I'll compare 2 domestic pumpkin ales and we'll see how the seeds fall.
Blue Moon Pumpkin Ale: Color-Clear dark amber Nose-Fresh First taste-Smooth Observations-Nice taste Fizziness-Average head; active bubbles Where Brewed? Golden, Col.(Molson-Coors) Cost-$1.16 Style-Pumpkin Ale Saying-6 spices & crystal malt Aftertaste-Steady Rating-7.5
Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale: Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Spicy First taste-Medicinal Observations-Smoother on second sip Fizziness-Average head; light carbonation Cost-$1.20 Style-Pumpkin Ale Saying-Cucurbin Pepo (Pumpkin) Aftertaste-Too sharp Rating-7
Final Thought-Blue moon slightly more tasty!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Foreign Pilsner vs. Domestic Lager

2008-10-27T07:40:00.000-07:00

Audrey's mom has come through her surgery well thus far and life goes on in NYC. This tasting will pit a Polish pilsner against a Pa. lager from Pottsville.
Kiper (Browar): Color-Slightly cloudy; yellow golden Nose-Clean First taste-Strong; full mouth Observations-Foreign feel; like other Polish beers Fizziness-Rim head; average bubbles Cost-$1.25 Container-13.52 oz. bottle Style-Pilsner Aftertaste-Stays steady Where brewed? Piotrkow Tryb, Poland Rating-7.5
Yeungling: Color-Amber Nose-Fresh First taste-Back throat Observations-Pleasant taste Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Cost-$.65 Container-12 oz. bottle Style-Lager Aftertaste-Good Where Brewed? Pottsville, Pa. Rating-7
Final thought-Kiper with imported taste better; More bang for buck in Yeungling (Oldest brewery in USA-1829)
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Encore

2008-10-27T07:36:00.000-07:00

Audrey's moms operation is today and thusfar all has gone well. I am introducing a Smuttynose Brewing ale to 2 others which have been evaluated in the past.
Pass Time Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy golden Nose-Funky First taste-Not positive Observations-Flattens out Fizziness-Rim head; average bubbles Where brewed-Boulder, Col. Cost-$.79 Container-12 oz.bottle Style-Pale ale Saying-Colorado's first micro Aftertaste-Not memorable Rating-6
Porkslap (Farmhouse) Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy golden Nose-Of cloves; spices First taste-Unusual Observations-Different strange taste Where brewed? Garrattsville, NY Cost-$1.11 Container- 12 oz. can Style-Pale ale Saying-2 Pigs on can-"All Malt" Aftertaste-Weird Rating-6.75
Shoal's Pale Ale: Color-Clear amber red Nose-Earthy First taste-Full mouth Observations-Strong; full bodied Fizziness-Consistent head; hardly any bubbles Where brewed? Portsmouth, NH Cost-$1.31 Style-Pale ale Saying-Reminiscent of Smuttynose Island Aftertaste-Smooth Rating-7.50
Final Thought-Shoal's (Smuttynose Brewery) the class of this threesome!!! Addendum-Pass Time's ratings have been dropping; I suspect the shelf life might be the issue.
Signed:Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

All Style Beer Tasting

2008-10-20T08:44:00.000-07:00

Fall is in the air as Audrey and I head to Kennedy airport to see my sister Linda en route to Istanbul, Turkey. Audrey will leave for her mom in Florida later in the day. Mike Kagan's apartment will provide the base for our first beer tasting ever that evaluates 5 separate types.
1. Nashoba Bolt 117 Premium Lager (Bolton, Mass.): Cloudy golden; fruity; frothy head; average carbonation; full mouth; full bodied; reminiscent of Midwest lagers; slight aftertaste; everlasting foam Baron-7.5 Mike-8 Avg.-7.75
2. Knight's Head Pale Ale (Wilkes-Barre, Pa.): Floral; fruity; hoppy dryness on second taste; smooth; drinkable; rim head Baron-7 Mike-7.5 Avg.-7.25
3. Saranac Brown Ale (Utica, NY): Rim head; chocolate brown; fruity; caramel; smooth; well balanced; good carbonation; goes down easy; chocolate caramel nose Baron-8 Mike-9 Avg.-8.5
4. South Hampton Secret Ale (brewed in Saratoga Springs, NY): Rim head; dark copper; not distinctive taste in first sip; like flat Coco-cola; light bubbles; not much nose (slight floral); some dry hoppy; but not substantial Baron-6 Mike-3 Avg.-4.5
5. Blue Moon Harvest Moon Pumpkin Ale (Golden,Colorado): Copper color; fresh crispy smell; lightly fruity; spicy Baron-7.5 Mike-8.5 Avg.-8
6. Northern Reserve Golden Lager (Cold Spring,Mn.): Refreshing; Midwestern taste; slightly of hops; yellow golden color; GUZZLE, don't SIP!!! Baron-5 Mike-5 Avg.-5
Signed-Mike Komaroff (BeerBaron) & Mike Kagan

Dark Beers

2008-10-14T09:12:00.000-07:00

Yesterday Audrey and I went to our new Trader Joe's in downtown Brooklyn. Unlike the store at Union Sq. in Manhattan, this one does not sell wine or champagne. Yet it does have beer and its own brands as well. I purchased a 6-pak of the dark and it will be involved in this tasting.
Saranac Black Forest: Color-Reddish dark brown Nose-Fresh; clean First taste-Back throat Observations-Nice balance Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Mild head; active bubbles Cost-$1.05 Style-Bavarian Aftertaste-Full mouth Rating-7.25
Trader Joe's Dark: Color-Dark amber Nose-Syrupy First taste-Full mouth Observations-Porter type taste; then fades Where brewed? Tecate, BC, Mexico Fizziness-Rim head; active bubbles Cost-$1.08 Style-Dark premium lager Aftertaste-Taste is leaving Rating-6.5
Final Thought-Black Forest is better!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

European Style Lagers

2008-10-14T08:58:00.000-07:00

St. Pauli Girl Lager: Color-Bright golden Nose-Of grain First taste-Smooth; good taste Observations-Well balanced Fizziness-Light head; active bubbles Cost-$1.00 Style-German lager Where Brewed? Bremen, Germany Ingredients-Subject to Reinsgebot Aftertaste-Memorable Rating-7.5
Trader Joe's Bohemian Lager: Color-Off yellow cloudy Nose-None First taste-Strong; flattens out Observations-Fast fade Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Cost-$1.00 Style-Bohemian lager Where brewed? San Jose, Cal. Ingredients-Imported pilsner malted barley; aroma hops Aftertaste-Earthy Rating-6
Final Thought-German import still very good; domestic lager not impressive!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

INDIA PALE ALE Re-explored

2008-10-14T08:54:00.000-07:00

The usual group has been assembled in Greenwood Heights; that includes the Aleman, the BeerBaron and the Icegirl.
Victory Hop Devil: Alc.#6.7% Aftertaste bitter grapefruit; Full at outset; then becomes more bitter; dried fruit nose; sweet backbite; smooth finish; lasting taste; not crispy; warmth in throat Gary-7.25 Mike-7.5 Rita-7 Avg.-7.25
LaGunitas IPA: Grapefruity; bitter tasting; more crispy; fast fade; sour pineapple Gary-6.5 Mike-7.75 Rita-7.5 Avg.-7.25
Weyerbacher Simcoe IPA: Alc.#9% Hint of maple syrup; real hoppy outburst at onset; taste stays; bitter backbite; earthy; can taste alcohol Gary-7 Mike-7.5 Rita-7 Avg.-7.166
Snapperhead IPA: Blah to watery finish; Slightly crispy; watery on tongue; light; nice(in subtle way); Guzzle don't savor!!! Gary-5 Mike-6 Rita-4.5 Avg.-5.166
Signed: Gary J. Sweeney, Mike Komaroff, & Rita Renella

Black & Tan Toasting

2008-10-14T08:52:00.000-07:00

Black & Tan is a combination of stout/porter with lager or premium lager. At a Guinness event at Sony Studio's last year we combined Guinness w/Harp creating fanfare. Here we have 2 domestic brewers examples of this style.
Saranac: Color-Brown w/ yellow tinge Nose-Fresh; of caramel First taste-Full mouth; then fades Observations-Smooths out Fizziness-Frothy; active bubbles Cost-$1.05 Where Brewed? Utica, NY Saying-Brewed in the Adirondack Foothills Ingredients-Stout & Lager Aftertaste-Good; consistent Rating-7.25
Yeungling: Color-Brown w/ reddish orange hue Nose-Medicinal First taste-Striking; slightly levels out Observations-Taste is lasting Fizziness-Frothy head; few bubbles Cost-$.86.5 cents Where Brewed? Pottsville, Pa. Saying-America's Oldest Brewery-Since 1829 Ingredients-Porter & Premium Aftertaste-Not memorable; too sharp Rating-6.25
Final Thought-Saranac B&T smoother and more tasty; Yeungling B&T excellent on tap!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Outside the Pale (Ale)

2008-10-14T08:50:00.000-07:00

Audrey's back to school tomorrow following our Jewish New Year's respite. Pale ales have been in my radar of late. Two domestic examples are ready for tonight's tasting; hopefully they will do well.
Magic Hat #9: Color-Yellowish gold clear Nose-Hoppy First taste-Nice taste Observations-Smooth; full mouth Fizziness-Medium foam; active bubbles Cost-$1.31 Where Brewed? So. Burlington, Vt Saying-Not quite pale ale; Alc. 4.6% Aftertaste-Balanced; steady Rating-7.5
Porkslap Pale (Farmhouse Ale): Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Earthy(funky) First taste-A bit medicinal Observations-Taste overpowering Fizziness-Light fizz; few bubbles Cost-$1.11 Where brewed? Garrattsville, NY Saying-2 Pigs on Can;(ALL MALT) Aftertaste-All encompassing; not pleasant Rating-6.75
Final Thought-Magic Hat always produces great products; this one does not disappoint.
Mike Komaoff BeerBaron

Saranac Ales

2008-10-01T01:25:00.000-07:00

It's the weekend and as good a time as any to taste some fine Saranac ales.
Saranac Belgian Ale: Color-Amber clear Nose-Fresh First taste-Nice taste Observations-Flavor remains Fizziness-Rim head; few active bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05 Aftertaste-Remember it Rating-7
Winter Wassel: Color-Dark amber clear Nose-Non-descript First taste-Back throat Observations-To palate Fizziness-Mild head; few active bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-$1.05 Aftertaste-OK; not great Rating-5.75
Final Thought-Saranac maintains its' pre-eminent position. To Aleman-"We love Saranac."
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Belgian Style Ales

2008-10-01T01:23:00.000-07:00

Audrey is spending extra time fund raising at her school during curriculum night. I plan on joining her for an hour and a half following my beer baron duties of checking out 2 domestic examples of Belgium style ales.
Saranac Belgian Ale: Color-Clear dark amber Nose-Sweet First taste-Smooth Observations-Taste holds steady Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Mild head; many active bubbles Cost-$1.05 Description-Fruity Ale w/ Belgian aromatic malt Aftertaste-Back throat Rating-7
Victory Golden Monkey: Color-Cloudy Golden Nose-Funky sweet First taste-Full mouth Observations-Can taste alcohol Where brewed? Downingtown, Pa. Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Cost-Gift Description-Tripel ale w/ spices; 9.5% alc. Aftertaste-Still strong Rating-7
Final thought-Not really competing ales since Golden Monkey is a Belgian tripel; Saranac is a straight Belgian ale.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

COORS (Banquet)

2008-10-01T01:21:00.000-07:00

Audrey is on jury duty trying to make it a one day affair. Since we have reached the date on the bottom of the 24 oz. when the beer is deemed fading I will do my rating now.
Coors (Banquet): Color-Golden yellow Nose-Not much smell First taste-Strong; fast fade Observations-Goes down easy Where Brewed? Headqtrs. Golden, Col.-Probably brewed in their Virginia subsidiary Cost-$1.00 Alc.#-5% Saying-A brand that has stood the test of time. Brewed with 100% Rocky Mountain water for a legendary taste. Aftertaste-Some slight Rating-4
Final Thought-In 24 oz. can was at a good price!!! Not with the same tradition or quality of what it was when not available nationwide.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Personified

2008-10-01T01:18:00.000-07:00

NY Giants are being challenged by the Bengals today. I will taste my share of representative pale ales all of which I have evaluated before.
Knight's Head Pale Ale: Color-Amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Full mouth Observations-Smooth; nice Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Fizziness-Light head; more bubbles Aftertaste-Lasting Rating-7.25 Cost-$.42 (Bargain of Century)
Pass Time Pale Ale: Color-Amber Nose-Fresh First taste-Funky Observations-Not great Where Brewed? Boulder, Col. Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Aftertaste-None Rating-6.5 Cost-$.79
Saranac Pale Ale: Color-Darker amber Nose-Slight hops First taste-Full mouth Observations-Good taste Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Light head; more bubbles Aftertaste-Some Rating-7 Cost-$1.05
Final Thought-True value Knight's Head again!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Premonition

2008-10-01T01:16:00.000-07:00

Another Pale Ale tasting with an ale new to me going against one of my regulars.
Pass Time Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Funky First taste-Quick taste Observations-Fast fade Fizziness-Rim head; active bubbles Where Brewed? Boulder, Col. Container-12 oz. bottle Cost-$.79 Aftertaste-Some is there Rating-6.75
Porkslap Pale Ale (Farmhouse Ale): Color-Amber; more yellowish Nose-Of cloves; floral First taste-Nice taste Observations-Well balanced Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Garrattsville, NY Container-12 oz. can copper colored with pigs jumping Cost-$1.11 Aftertaste-Pleasant; of spices Rating-7.5
Final Thoughts- Was reminiscent of another ale!!! My second encounter with a product from Butternuts Beer and Ale-Both the IPA and the PA have been above average (Rating-7.5); these and two others are available at the Park Slope Food Co-op!!!

Snapperhead IPA (Farmhouse Ale)

2008-10-01T01:14:00.000-07:00

Snapperhead IPA (Farmhouse Ale): Color-Cloudy Amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Back throat Observations-Quick fade Fizziness-Thick foam(dissipates); very few bubbles Where Brewed? Garrettsville, NY Container-12oz. yellow can w/shark in green embossed Aftertaste-Some lingering taste Rating-7
Final Thought-First product tried (PS Food Co-op has 3 others, the Pale Ale I already bought)!!!

Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Wrap Around

2008-10-01T01:12:00.000-07:00

I'm continuing with my pale tastings by trying an ale Audrey bought me in Savannah, Ga.; it will go up against a pale ale from Boulder, Colorado I've rated before. This is my last in this series but I will look again at my food co-op for other pale ales which can enter this process.
Pass Time Pale Ale: Color-Amber cloudy Nose-Funky First Taste-Strong; back throat Observations-Alright; not consistent Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Where Brewed? Boulder, Colorado Cost-$.79 After taste-On palate Rating-6.75

Sweetwater 420 Extra Pale Ale: Color-Golden clear Nose-Hoppy First taste-Tasty; full mouth Observations-Pleasant; very good Fizziness-Rim head; carbonation Where Brewed? Atlanta, Ga. Cost-Gift(More than $1.50) Aftertaste-Lasting Rating-7.5
Final thought-Sweetwater 420 was more consistent; Pass Time alright.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Revisited

2008-10-01T01:09:00.000-07:00

This is another tasting in the Knight's Head Pale Ale challenge series. The opponent tonight is from the Rocky Mts. of Colorado (Pass Time Pale Ale). I am dedicating this one to the Galveston/Houston areas of Texas that were devastated earlier today by Hurricane Ike. Hopefully the people there can put their lives back together soon. Our thought and prayers are with them. Here goes:
Knight's Head Pale Ale-Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Hoppy First taste-Pleasant; rewarding Observations-First rate taste Fizziness-Light head; many active bubbles Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Cost-$.42 Aftertaste-Lingering; it's good!!! Rating-7
Pass Time Pale Ale-Color-Cloudy amber Nose-Fresh First taste-Nice Observations-Taste does fade Fizziness-Rim head; many active bubbles Where Brewed? Boulder, Col. Cost-$.79 Aftertaste-Some; not bad Rating-6.50
Final Thought-Can't say enough about how good the Knight's Head Pale is for the money!!! A truly exceptional value!!!

Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Light Beer (MUST DO THIS)

2008-10-01T01:04:00.000-07:00

Light(Lite) beer is one class that I do not regularly drink; yet I feel rating them is in my area of expertise. Most people drink these brews to take in fewer calories/carbs but sacrifice taste, balance, and satisfaction in the process.
Knight's Head Light-Container-12 oz. bottle Color-Yellow Nose-None First taste-Not much taste Observations-Does not impress Fizziness-Slight head; active bubbles Cost-$.42 Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Aftertaste-Not impressive Rating-3.50
Miller Lite-Container-12 oz. can Color-Yellow Nose-None First taste-Flat Observations-Not very good Fizziness-Slight head; few bubbles Cost-Gift Where brewed? Milwaukee, Wis. Aftertaste-Forget it Rating-3.25
Final Thought-Certainly if all light beers taste this bad, steer clear of them. Like recently tasted Northern Lager, this stuff must be chugged not sipped.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Lager in Fall Cool Off

2008-09-10T09:42:00.000-07:00

This is the second beer I am trying from my case of Knight Head products brewed in Wilkes-Barre, Pa. by the Round Table Brewing Company. I will be comparing their lager with St. Pauli Girl from Germany. Here goes:
Knight Head Lager: Color-Amber Nose-Of grain First taste-Back throat Observations-Strong taste; then fades Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Fizziness-Frothy head; active bubbles Cost-$.42 Saying-Brewing Refined Aftertaste-Not formidable Rating-5.75
St. Pauli Girl Lager: Color-Yellowish Nose-Fresh First taste-Tasty; full mouth Observations-Imported feel Where brewed? Bremen, Germany Fizziness-Frothy head; good carbonation Cost-$1.00 Saying-Sexy Barmaid-"Octoberfest" Aftertaste-Pleasing Rating-7.25
Final Thought-A very good German lager was too much for the Pa. product.

Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Repeated

2008-09-10T09:40:00.000-07:00

This is the second in a series of comparisons between Knight's Head Ale and other popular pale ales brewed in the US. Let's begin this rating with the finals of the US Open Tennis Tournament for women being the backdrop.
Knight's Head Pale Ale: Color-Cloudy golden Nose-Fresh hoppy First taste-Back throat Observations-Flavor; then fade Fizziness-Rim head; active bubbles Where Brewed? Wilkes-Barre, Pa. Cost-$.42 Container-12 oz. bottle Style-Pale Ale Saying-Brewing Refined Aftertaste-Some on taste buds Rating-6.5
Troeg's Pale Ale: Color-Yellowish Nose-Real Hoppy First taste-Full mouth; grapefruit Observations-Taste endures; balanced Fizziness-Medium head; few lazy bubbles Where Brewed? Harrisburg, Pa. Cost-$1.36 Container-12 oz. bottle; 5.4% alc. Style-Pale Ale Saying-Independent Craft Brewery Aftertaste-Smoothness lingers Rating-7.5
Final Thought-Troeg's very good pale ale; Knight's Head real value for the money!!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Pale Ale Tasting

2008-09-10T09:38:00.000-07:00

This series of pale ale tastings will include Knight's Head Pale Ale brewed by Round Table Brewing of Wilkes-Barre, Pa. I picked up an assorted case including a 1/2 case of the pale plus a six-pak of both the lager and the light. My purchase was made for the astoundingly low price of $9.99 for twenty four 12 oz. bottles at West Chester, Pa. just across from the Delaware border. Onward and into sipping mode:
Geary's Pale Ale: Color-Orange golden Nose-Fresh First taste-Full taste Observations-Flavor is lasting Fizziness-Frothy head; many active bubbles Where Brewed? Geary Brewing of Portland, Me. Cost-$1.41 Container-12 oz. bottle Saying-Made in Maine Aftertaste-Some is there Rating-7
Knight's Head Pale Ale: Color-Golden Nose-Of yeast First taste-Full mouth Observations-Still Balanced Fizziness-Rim head; active bubbles Where Brewed? Round Table Brewing of Wilkes=Barre, Pa. Cost-$.42 Container-12 oz. bottle Saying-Brewing Refined Rating-6.5
Final Thought-Knight's Head on my all time bargain list!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Canadian Brewed Foster

2008-09-10T09:36:00.000-07:00

It's Labor Day at the beachclub and the weekend has been dynamic and beautiful. Tomorrow I will head to Newark, Delaware to bring the rest of Bryce's stuff to her as she begins her sophomore year at UDel. Our beer tasting today will be a Canadian brewed Australian product Foster found today in a 25.4 oz. can. On we go:
Foster (Canadian Brewed): Color-Golden yellow Nose-Of grain First taste-Strong; drinkable Observations-Taste alright Where Brewed? Toronto, Canada Fizziness-Foamy head; small active bubbles Type-Lager Aftertaste-Not noticable Rating-7
Final Thought-Unfortunately cannot remember the original brew from down under?
Mike Komaroff

BeerBaron

Very "CHEAP" Beers

2008-09-10T09:33:00.000-07:00

With Audrey getting a perm in Bay Ridge, I choose not to go to the beach. I will compare 2 cheap beers by all standards. Generally the only way to pay 50 cents per 12 ounces is to get a 24 oz. can of Coors/Coors Lite or one of the ice beers. Here we have 2 of that variety; I did have to buy a case/6-pak respectively to get the excellent price. On we go:
Northern (Reserve) Golden Beer: Color-Golden yellow Nose-Non descript First taste-Strong first burst Observations-Not much taste lingers Fizziness-Rim head; active bubbles Where Brewed? Cold spring, MN. Cost-21 cents per 12 ozs. Style(Type)-Lager Aftertaste-Not memorable Rating-4
Old Harbour Pilsner Lager: Color-Light yellow Nose-Slight First Taste-Full mouth Observations-Not lasting Fizziness-Frothy head; many active bubbles Where Brewed? Utica, NY Cost-50 cents per 12 ozs. Style(Type) Pilsner Lager Aftertaste-Metallic Rating-4.5
Final Thought-If you're looking for a cheap drunken binge, these are both excellent choices. They are not to be sipped and savored.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Northern Golden Lager (amazing cheap price)!!!

2008-09-10T09:28:00.000-07:00

Here I am tasting a lager beer that I purchased a case of earlier today at a Thrifty Beverage in Sheepshead Bay. I am dedicating it to Audrey's Aunt Rosie who died yesterday only 75 years old. Let me begin:
Northern (Reserve) Golden Lager: Color-Golden yellow Nose-Not able to discern any scent First taste-Strong; then fast fade Observations-Drinkable if you don't expect much Fizziness-Rim head(then it goes away too); few active bubbles Where Brewed? Cold Spring, Minnesota Cost-21 cents per 12oz. can($4.99 a case) Aftertaste-Not pleasant Rating-4
Final Thought-Not high on my list of beers; yet it still is worth what I paid for it. Plan on trying a tasting soon against a 50 center beer (a pilsner from Utica, NY) Audrey can also use the Northern Lager as a base which she can add juices to forming a malt beverage.
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Heineken Mini-Keg

2008-09-10T09:24:00.000-07:00

Silver Gull Beach Club in the Rockaways again provides the backdrop for another taste and rate event. Our next store cabana neighbor Russ Marcus provided the suds and I did my evaluation. Heineken Mini-Keg: Color-Golden yellow Nose-Clean; fresh First taste- Some taste; quick fade Observations-Goes down easy; Not as good as its' full keg sized brethren(sample could have also been better refrigerated) Fizziness-Frothy head; slight carbonation Aftertaste-Pleasant but doesn't last long Rating-6
Final thought-I again encounter the on tap vs. bottle/can concept. Generally draft type beers are more highly rated.
Signed-Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Blockparty IPA Extraganza

2008-09-10T09:19:00.000-07:00

The regular crew is again assembled at my brownstone south of Park Slope in Brooklyn. We will be evaluating another set of IPA's from around the US.
1)Magic Hat Roxy Rolles(Vt.): Burnt molasses; pleasant; not overpowering; smoothness; creamy slight bitterness Gary-6.5 Mike-7.25 Rita-7 Avg.-6.916
2)Smuttynose IPA(NH): Very bitter(grapefruit seed like); bitterness lingers; Bitterness overpowering; not pleasant taste Gary-5 Mike-6 Rita-5 Avg.-5.666
3)Red Hook Long Hammer IPA(NH): Slightly bitter; crispy; stays on taste buds; some positive taste; "Smoothness to the Bitterness" Gary-7 Mike-7 Rita-6 Avg.-6.666
4)Saranac IPA(NY): Crispy like the Longhammer IPA; Hint of burnt molasses; hits whole mouth; smoothness; tiny bitterness lingers; pleasant tasting; bitterness on side of tongue remains. Gary-6.5 Mike-7 Rita-6.5 Avg.-6.666
Entire tasting will be regarded as a resounding success!!! Signed: Gary Sweeney, Mike Komaroff, & Rita Renella Witnessed by: Audrey Komaroff

Ales w/spices

2008-09-10T09:14:00.000-07:00

At the beachclub again on a nice sunny day with low humidity and temps. in the low 80's. Audrey will join the rating process with me as this is the type of brew she fancies.
Blue Moon Pumpkin: Color-Burnt orange Nose-Of spice First taste-Smooth; full mouth Observations-Pumpkin effect Where Brewed? Toronto, Canada Fizziness-Rim head; light carbonation Cost-$1.16 Aftertaste-Nice Rating-Audrey-8 Mike-7 Avg.-7.5
Saranac Winter Wassel: Color-Brown Nose-Of cinnamon & orange First taste-Slightly bitter Observations-Spice blend Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Rim head; light carbonation Cost-$1.05 Aftertaste-Alright Rating-Audrey-7 Mike-6.5 Avg.-6.75
Final Thought-Blue Moon better balanced!!!

Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Re-Test Saratoga Springs, NY

2008-08-15T12:39:00.000-07:00

Great sunny weather has again lured me to the Rockaways and our beachclub. Today is time for a do over of an earlier tasting done earlier in '08. It will pit two lagers brewed in the same town probably in the same brewery space.
Red Tail Lager: Color-Orange Nose-Fresh First taste-Strong; back throat Observations-Even taste Cost-$1.00 Fizziness-Rim head; few bubbles Saying-"The Legend Grows" Brewer-Mendocino Aftertaste-Settle in with it Rating-7.25
Saratoga Lager: Color-Burnt orange Nose-Fresh First taste-More harsh Observations-Aggressive taste Cost-$1.00 Fizziness-Rim head; more bubbles Saying-"Marzenbier" Brewer-Olde Saratoga Aftertaste-Too much blast Rating-6.5
Final Thought-Red Tail better!!!
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Rocky Mountain Hoppy

2008-08-15T12:37:00.000-07:00

I have a challenge on my hands at Silver Gull Beach Club as I will consume 22 ozs.of a 6.8% alcohol IPA. Might as well get started:
Mojo IPA: Color-Cloudy orange Nose-Hoppy First taste-Intense hops Observations-Hoppiness on and on Fizziness-Rim head; slight carbonation Where Brewed? Boulder, Col. Factoid-Reminiscent of Lagunitas IPA Ingredients-Amarillo hops, water Aftertaste-Appealing Rating-7.5
Saying-"A bewitching ale that summons hop attacks."
Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

IPA Alchemy

2008-08-15T12:34:00.000-07:00

Powerful thunderstorms hit the NYC metro area yesterday causing hail and lowering the temps. to fall levels. We decided not to go to the beachclub and did laundry instead. Audrey is also recovering from a broken toe so did not want to exercise in the pool. We're watching the Olympic coverage on NBC as I begin another ALE event. Let's begin the rating game:
Saranac IPA: Color-Golden amber Nose-Of hops First taste-Full mouth Observations-Good taste; flattens out Where Brewed? Utica, NY Fizziness-Foamy head; active bubbles Cost-$1.05 Ingredients-Cascade hops, water Aftertaste-Is there but not distinctive Rating-7.25
Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale: Color-Cloudy dark amber Nose-More hoppy First taste-Smooth hops burst Observations-Maintains balance Where Brewed? Chico, Cal. Fizziness-Very foamy; slight carbonation Cost-$1.29 Alc#-6.8% Ingredients-Not True IPA, but plenty hoppy Aftertaste-Can't wait for '08 entry Rating-7.75
FINAL THOUGHT-Celebration Ale consistent winner!!! Mike Komaroff BeerBaron

Flavored Beer(Lime)

2008-08-15T12:33:00.000-07:00

Here I am back at the beachclub on another promising summer day with no humidity and beautiful cloud formations. I prepare to taste Budweisers' entry product into the flavored(Corona) like market. The bottle of the Bud Light Lime has labeling like the Mexican beer which is known for sections of lemons or limes being inserted into it while drinking. Here goes:
BUD LIGHT LIME: Color-Yellow golden Nose-Slight lime First taste-Light lime; flattens out Observations-No continuing taste Fizziness-Light head; Active big bubbles Where Brewed? St. Louis, Mo.(headquarters) Fruit essence-Lime Alc.#-4.2% Aftertaste-Forget this stuff Rating-(Audrey)3 Mike-3.5 Avg.-3.25
This beer tasting is dedicated to the memory of comedian Bernie Mac!!!
Mike & Audrey Komaroff

Pale Ale Tasting

2008-08-15T12:30:00.000-07:00

IPA's have been highlighted of late; I will take on two of IPA's less hoppy cousins this morning. Pass Time Pale Ale: Color-Dark golden Nose-Of hops First Taste-Full mouth Observations-Taste doesn't last Fizziness-Foamy head; Active bubbles Cost-79 cents Where Brewed? Boulder, Col. Style-Pale Ale Saying-Colorado's First Microbrewery Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Some; not memorable Rating-7.25
Saranac Pale Ale: Color-Reddish golden Nose-Slight Sweetness First taste-Strong malty Observations-Nice taste Fizziness-Foamy head; Active bubbles Cost-$1.05 Where brewed? Utica, NY Style-Pale Ale Saying-From the Adirondacks Container-12 oz. bottle Aftertaste-Good finish Rating-7.75
FINAL THOUGHT-Saranac in a close one!!! Mike Komaroff BeerBaron